The Synod of Whitby

by | May 7, 2021 | The Early Church


Juliet220, CC BY-SA 3.0, via Wikimedia Commons

Puffing and panting, I finally scaled the 199 steps leading to the ruins of Whitby Abbey, once called Streanaeshalch. Catching my breath and admiring the view of the Yorkshire fishing town, I turned to look at the ruined building. The original abbey does not exist, having been destroyed by the Danes in the ninth century, so the ruins I was staring at are from a later period of the Benedictines. I tried to time-travel in my mind back to the year 664, picturing the famous Synod of Whitby, when the destiny of Britain would be shaped for almost nine hundred years.

King Oswy of Northumbria, deeply concerned to see a division in the church mended, summoned church leaders to assemble at Hilda’s double-monastery of Celtic monks and nuns. The delegates, often travelling long distances, gathered to solve several issues in the church: in particular, that of when to celebrate Easter. Colman, representing the Scottish view, was given the first round, according to Bede. ‘The Easter customs which I observe were taught me by my superiors, who sent me here as bishop; and all our forefathers, men beloved of God, are known to have observed these customs,’ Colman said, ‘And lest anyone condemn or reject them as wrong, it is recorded that they owe their origin to the blessed evangelist saint John, the disciple especially loved by our Lord, and all the churches over which he presided.’

Wilfrid, representing the Roman opinion, responded that they celebrated Easter on the first Sunday after Nisan 14 in the Jewish calendar, a custom which was practiced by the universal church, coming from Peter and Paul in Rome, and confirmed at the Council of Nicaea in AD 325. ‘The only people who stupidly contend against the whole world,’ he replied, ‘are these Scots and their partners in obstinacy, the Picts and Britons.’ When Colman tried to rebut Wilfrid by again calling on the authority of the Apostle John, Wilfrid confounded him by adding that John observed the Jewish Law of Moses for the Passover, celebrating Easter every year on that same date, ‘not caring whether it fell on the Sabbath or on any other day’. On the other hand, the Scots and others in Britain had their own Sunday Easter date, separate from the universal church.

In the end King Oswy quoted from Scripture that Christ had given Peter ‘the keys of the kingdom of heaven’, thus he must be the authority in these matters. When both Colman and Wilfrid agreed on this, the Easter problem was initially solved. Those on Lindisfarne received the news from Colman that they must abandon their old Scottish customs and fall into line with Rome; Iona followed suit about 40 years later. As such, a milestone had now been established in Scotland: instead of there being two church groups working side by side, there now became one uniform church under Rome. A new era had begun.

Christian Heritage Edinburgh
Christian Heritage Edinburgh logo
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.

You can adjust all of your cookie settings by navigating the tabs on the left hand side.

You can also read our full Privacy Policy here.